| Name | Total | Name | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| McGregor | 1 | Orchard | 1 |
| McInnes | 1 | Orr | 1 |
| McLaren | 2 | Ortlepp | 2 |
| McMahon | 3 | Osborne | 1 |
| McNab | 1 | O’Byrne | 1 |
| McNamara | 1 | O’Dowd | 1 |
| McPhee | 1 | O’Farrell | 2 |
| Meaney | 3 | O’Flynn | 1 |
| Mee | 8 | O’Grady | 3 |
| Milde | 4 | O’Niell | 1 |
| Miller | 2 | O’Reilly | 1 |
| Mills | 6 | O’Shea | 2 |
| Milne | 4 | O’Sullivan | 1 |
| Mitchell | 3 | Palmer | 2 |
| Moffatt | 8 | Parker | 1 |
| Moffitt | 6 | Parkes | 1 |
| Moir | 1 | Parkinson | 4 |
| Monks | 3 | Partridge | 1 |
| Moore | 16 | Paterson | 70 |
| Moreland | 2 | Patten | 2 |
| Morgan | 4 | Patterson | 4 |
| Morgenstern | 3 | Peake | 6 |
| Morley | 3 | Pendar | 1 |
| Morris | 1 | Penhall | 1 |
| Moss | 9 | Percy | 1 |
| Moyse | 1 | Perry | 2 |
| Mudge | 6 | Peters | 1 |
| Muir | 11 | Peterson | 2 |
| Mullins | 1 | Phillips | 5 |
| Munday | 4 | Philp | 1 |
| Murphy | 19 | Physick | 3 |
| Murray-Smith | 1 | Pickering | 1 |
| Murrin | 4 | Picking | 5 |
| Nation | 1 | Pimm | 1 |
| Neal | 1 | Pitt | 3 |
| Neale | 3 | Platten | 1 |
| Needs | 3 | Plummer | 2 |
| Neuman | 1 | Pluzek | 1 |
| Nicholas | 1 | Pollard | 1 |
| Nichols | 1 | Poole | 1 |
| Nickels | 5 | Pople | 3 |
| Niejalke | 12 | Porter | 1 |
| Nilson | 1 | Possingham | 1 |
| Nixon | 3 | Potter | 3 |
| Noack | 3 | Pottinger | 1 |
| Norris | 1 | Powell | 4 |
| Norsworthy | 17 | Prange | 2 |
| Northcott | 3 | Pratt | 1 |
| Noske | 4 | Preston | 1 |
| Obst | 3 | Price | 2 |